She said: “We found out that a decorator took them down while he was working here in the 1970s and then was involved in a serious car accident at the top of the road.
“Phil once happened to touch the witch by accident and the following day he fell through a trapdoor leading to the cellar and broke his collarbone.
“Someone else fell over the following week and broke both his knees. It's spooky.”
Linda says she was convinced something terrible would happen after she learned about the theft.
She said: “One of my bar staff, Charlie, saw a man take the witch from the ceiling on the Friday night and run out. He wasn't a regular because they all know the story.
“I suppose I am superstitious because I used to say to the witches 'I tell people not to touch you so look after me' but when I found out one had gone I said ‘oh God something bad’s going to happen now.
“We live above the pub and on Sunday we woke up about 7.45am to the sound of smashing downstairs.
“I thought someone had broken in and was using a baseball bat until Les went downstairs and found it was a fire.
“It was terrifying. If it wasn't for the prompt response of the fire service the Mags might have burned to the ground.”
The remaining witch and devil were found in the scorched remains of the bar after the fire on April 18 but Linda says they have since vanished.
A friend bought the couple a replacement witch from Pendle which now hangs in their place.
They are celebrating the pub's re-opening with a beer and cider festival next week which will include a special brew, Witches Revenge.
Linda said: “What happened was so strange that I thought I'd better put the new witch up – just in case.”